Gemini creditors revolt over ‘brutal’ Bitcoin slashing reorg plan

Gemini Earn creditors are fuming over a proposed reorganization plan that could see their promised Bitcoin (BTC) payouts effectively slashed to about 30% of what they’re worth at current market rates.

In a post on X (formerly Twitter), Gemini Trust revealed it sent creditors an email on Dec. 13 outlining the proposed plan, which has now been put up for a vote.

Under the proposed plan, creditors will receive a payout equal to their Earn crypto balances as of Jan. 19, 2023 — the date that Gemini’s cryptocurrency lending partner Genesis Global Capital filed for bankruptcy.

Some observers, including Bloomberg exchange-traded fund analyst James Seyffart, described the plan as “brutal,” given that the prices of Bitcoin and Ether (ETH) were only $20,940 and $1,545 at the time. The assets have since rallied to $42,750 and $2,250, respectively, at the time of writing.

This could be brutal. Granted seems to be worst case scenario but Gemini Earn users could be getting potentially just 61% of the value of their crypto from Jan 19, 2023. WOOF.

Even at 100% it stings based on current prices. Thats 61%-100% of:

Bitcoin $20,940Ethereum $1,545 https://t.co/A6u28U3dsi pic.twitter.com/5SKZnlRjr9

— James Seyffart (@JSeyff) December 14, 2023

This would mean that in the worst-case scenario where creditors are given a 61% recovery, each Bitcoin that a creditor had on Earn would only be given $12,773, or 30% of what a Bitcoin is worth today.

Commenters of Gemini’s X post appeared in fierce opposition to the plan, with many of them urging creditors to “VOTE NO.”

#gemini #geminiearnVOTE NO pic.twitter.com/hz3ZrvoxWY

— jeffscottworld (️, ) (@jeffscottward) December 13, 2023

One X user, Andrew Aleid, said: “I vote no because this is a spit in our faces. Absolute disgrace.”

“You stole our money. Give it ALL back, every single dollar,” said another user, Leslie, in response to Gemini Trust’s post. She added:

“How can any of your customers believe a single word you say when you have deceived and lied to us for WELL over a year.” Leslie’s comments were made in reference to Gemini reassuring customers that it would not be subject to counterparty risk from Genesis.

Another X user, BC, said everyone should be paid back in full. “Anything less is unacceptable.”

After a year this is absolutely insane. You killed our souls. You damaged our hearts and health. We give you crypto coins and want our crypto back. The same amount. DCG forced you to do what ever they want. You couldn’t do anything!!! Unbelievable

— ANNA (@AvaAzadpour) December 14, 2023

Gemini Earn was a program where users earned interest in cryptocurrencies. Gemini withdrew hundreds of millions of dollars from Genesis to facilitate the program before Genesis went bankrupt.

The cryptocurrency exchange is now seeking to recover $1.6 billion from Genesis for Earn users.

Related: New York Attorney General sues Gemini, Genesis, DCG for allegedly defrauding investors

Creditors have until Jan. 10, 2024, at 4 pm Eastern Time to accept or reject Gemini’s plan.

If the plan is accepted, the bankruptcy court overlooking the case will decide whether it gives final approval on Feb. 14, 2024.

Magazine: Blockchain detectives: Mt. Gox collapse saw birth of Chainalysis